Kwam tijdens het googlen een interessante site tegen.
http://leerburg.com/schvsknpv.htm
Wat quotes die me opvielen:
"The KNPV is also known as the Royal Dutch Police Dog Sport. The name would imply that the sport trains police dogs. This is not correct, the dogs trained in KNPV can not and should not go directly into police service work."
"The fact is that many people who train in the KNPV still feel that the purpose of the sport is to provide dogs for service work."
"Many dog vendors in this country intentionally mislead people and police agencies into believing that both Schutzhund and KNPV dogs are qualified to become police service dogs simply because they have obtained a Schutzhund or a KNPV title. Nothing is further from the truth."
"Both dog sports train a dog to bite a man. But it's possible to train dogs in either dog sport to bite strictly using the dogs prey drive. A dog must be able to work in his “defensive drive” and in “fight drive” to be a functional police service dog."
"It is important to realize that schutzhund tracking is no where near police service tracking. The fact is that if a dog was "FORCE TRACKED" for sport work (which is common) it will not do police service tracking. These force tracked dogs do not like to track as a result of the force that was put on it in the force training. Service dogs need to be trained to track through drive and tracking at speed is an important part of this training."
"The schutzhund bite work is a very precise routine that dogs can be "programmed" to work through. ... Frankly through proper training dogs can easily be schutzhund titled but these same dogs can not come close to passing a selection test for police work, much less be trained to do the work."
"The problem is that the judges confuse "very active prey drive" in the bite work with true aggression."
"While the KNPV sport does not require the same level of precision as schutzhund, it does seem that a lot of Dutch trainers are very hard on their dogs in obedience. I think this is because of the fact that they have not been forced to develop other training methods because many of their Malinois (at least the ones selected for their sport) are so high in drive that they can take the force and still maintain drive."
"These people think that the KNPV is a much more difficult sport where only the tough survive. Unfortunately they are wrong. The KNPV is a great sport if one keeps in mind that it is "JUST A SPORT."
"I just feel that it is a mistake to think that all Schutzhund dogs and all KNPV dog's can become police service dogs. The facts are that very few of them have the drive or temperament for the work."
Hoe verhoudt Schutzhund zich tot ringsport en IPO?
Kloppen de uitspraken die deze man doet?
Ik weet niet goed wat je daar mee bedoelt
